PEO flexibility varies from provider to provider. Some professional employer organizations (PEOs) allow you to keep your existing medical plan or workers' compensation coverage, referred to as carve-outs. Others require you to use the PEO’s plans. Some PEOs let you choose the specific services you receive, while others bundle everything into one package.
At G&A, we structure our PEO services around flexibility because you shouldn't have to give up what's working to gain the support you need. We itemize our services so you can see exactly what you're getting and what you're paying for, and we offer carve-out options for your medical plan and workers' compensation coverage. For businesses that aren't ready for a PEO or have a robust in-house HR team, G&A also offers administrative services organization (ASO) and human capital management (HCM) solutions as part of its HR outsourcing services.
In this article, we’ll walk through how flexible PEO services can be, how carve-outs and itemized services work, what to consider if you’re not ready for a PEO, and how to tell if a flexible partnership is the right fit for your business.
Why Do Some Businesses Feel Like Their PEO Isn't Flexible Enough?
Some businesses feel their professional employer organization isn't flexible enough because most PEOs build their pricing and operations around a single master benefits plan and a standard package of services. There's a reason for that: Pooling all clients into one plan creates the buying power a PEO is known for, and for many businesses, that arrangement works well.
Other businesses arrive with strong relationships already in place. If you have a broker you trust or workers' compensation coverage that's working well, unwinding those relationships to join a PEO can cost more than it saves. That's often the moment when a business starts looking for a more flexible PEO because the standard package doesn't account for what they've already built.
What Does a Flexible PEO Model Actually Look Like?
A flexible PEO lets you choose how much support you want and which existing relationships you keep. At G&A, that comes in two forms: a standard PEO with itemized services and a PEO with carve-out options.
1. Standard PEO
A PEO is an HR outsourcing model built on co-employment, which means G&A and your business share certain employer responsibilities. You continue to run your business and make decisions about your people, while we take on administrative work such as payroll tax filings and benefits administration. In return, you gain access to our master benefits plan, workers' compensation program, and HR technology, along with guidance from our HR and compliance experts. For a deeper look, see our overview of what a PEO is.
Even in a standard PEO agreement, you have flexibility. We itemize our PEO services instead of combining them into a single price, so you can see exactly which services you're getting and what each one costs. You can add what your business needs, such as performance management or a learning management system (LMS), and leave out what it doesn't. Some PEOs charge one price for everything, which can mean paying for services you never use.
2. Carve-Out Options
A carve-out lets you keep your existing medical plan or workers' compensation coverage in place while you gain the rest of G&A's PEO services and support. This means you can maintain long-standing relationships with your broker or carrier. You still gain G&A's HR services and expertise, technology, and risk management support.
What Carve-Out Options Are Actually Available?
Carve-outs apply to two areas of the PEO relationship:
- Your medical plan, which lets you keep your broker
- Your workers' compensation coverage
In each case, you keep a relationship that's already working while gaining all the other benefits of a PEO.
Keep your broker and medical plan: Many businesses have worked with the same broker for years, and that relationship carries real value, including local market knowledge, a history of advocating for the business at renewal, and trust built over time. With a carve-out, G&A can administer the medical plan your broker has already placed, so you keep the advisor you trust while gaining administrative support, HR management, compliance guidance, and HR technology.
Keep your workers' compensation: G&A allows you to keep your existing workers' compensation coverage when you use our PEO services, something many PEOs do not offer. This can be beneficial if your program reflects a strong safety record or if you have an industry-specific carrier relationship. A carve-out lets you keep that coverage in place while G&A provides HR management, payroll administration, benefits admin, and compliance support elsewhere in the relationship.
What If You Aren't Ready for a PEO?
For businesses that aren't ready for a PEO or have a robust in-house HR team, G&A also offers ASO and HCM solutions as part of its HR outsourcing services.
ASO Services
Some businesses aren’t ready to share employer responsibilities through co-employment with a PEO. They may still be early in their growth or they may prefer to remain the sole employer of record. In these situations, an administrative services organization (ASO) offers another option for HR support.
ASO packages begin with payroll administration. From there, you choose the HR services you want to outsource, such as benefits administration, HR support, time and attendance, or compliance support, and you remain the sole employer. Because your business remains the employer of record, you also keep responsibility for payroll taxes and compliance, with G&A providing guidance and support.
HCM Solutions
A human capital management (HCM) solution is an HR technology platform backed by a team that helps you get the most out of it. You gain self-service tools for the full employee lifecycle, from onboarding and payroll to time tracking and reporting, along with personalized training and a responsive G&A team when you have questions. HCM works well for businesses that already have a person or team handling HR and want better tools with expert backup. As with an ASO, your business remains the sole employer of record.
How Do Flexible HR Providers Support Compliance?
A flexible HR provider supports compliance by pairing dedicated HR and risk professionals with your business, so we can flag changing federal and state employment requirements before they reach your desk.
In a full PEO relationship, G&A files payroll taxes on your behalf, helps manage ACA compliance requirements, and provides workers' compensation administration. If you carve out your medical plan, we can administer the plan on your behalf. It’s worth noting that certain safety-related services are only available if you participate in G&A’s workers’ compensation plan.
G&A’s experts track labor and employment laws and regulations at the federal and state levels, keep you informed, and guide you in creating policies that fit your business. Through our partnership, we can help reduce the risk of costly missteps, and you always have the final say on how your workplace runs.
That kind of hands-on support is also where responsiveness matters. G&A answers 88% of client service calls within 20 seconds, so when a compliance question comes up, you have a team that knows your business and can help you work through it.
How Do You Measure ROI from a Flexible PEO Partnership?
The clearest measure of ROI from a flexible PEO partnership is whether it gives your business room to grow without a matching increase in administrative overhead. Cost savings are the easiest number to point to, and they're rarely the full story.
Ask yourself two questions:
- Has your leadership team reclaimed hours once spent on payroll or benefits administration?
- Has turnover improved because HR support has gotten stronger without disrupting the relationships your team already trusts?
For most growing businesses, these answers matter more than the line-item cost because they show how much capacity the partnership gives back to your team.
Flexibility changes this calculation directly. A carve-out means you don't have to give up a workers' compensation program that reflects your strong safety record or a medical plan your employees already value just to gain a PEO's support. Because G&A itemizes our services, you also pay only for what you need. That efficiency, on top of the time savings and risk reduction a PEO relationship can provide, is where the real ROI tends to show up.
Is a Flexible PEO the Right Fit for Your Business?
A flexible PEO is a strong fit if you already have relationships in place that you want to keep, such as a broker you trust or a workers' compensation program that reflects your safety record. The goal is to build on what's already working.
It can also be a good fit if you have internal HR staff. G&A takes on time-consuming administrative work such as payroll processing and benefits administration, so your HR team can focus on priorities like culture and talent development. The same holds true for your employees, who tend to experience a well-designed carve-out as an upgrade in support, with the relationships they already count on still in place.
FAQs
Which PEOs are known for flexibility and carve-outs?
Flexibility varies widely across the PEO industry, so ask any provider you're evaluating whether they offer carve-out options and itemized services. G&A offers a standard PEO agreement and carve-out options.
For businesses that aren't ready for a PEO or have a robust in-house HR team, G&A also offers ASO and HCM solutions as part of its HR outsourcing options.
How flexible are PEO services?
It depends on the provider. Some PEOs offer one master plan with limited room to adjust it, while others, including G&A, let you choose which services you need and which to carve out, such as keeping your broker or your existing workers' compensation program.
Is a carve-out the same as picking services individually?
No. Picking services individually means choosing which HR services you want, such as adding performance management or an LMS to a PEO. A carve-out applies to your medical plan or workers' compensation coverage, and it lets you keep that coverage in place while you gain the rest of a PEO's services and support.
Can I keep my own broker if I work with a PEO?
Yes, you can keep your broker in a carve-out relationship. G&A can administer the medical plan your broker already has in place. You keep the advisor you trust while gaining administrative support, compliance guidance, and HR technology. For more on how the two work together, see our article on PEOs and brokers.
What's the difference between a PEO, an ASO, and an HCM solution?
In a PEO, you and G&A share certain employer responsibilities through co-employment, and you gain access to our HR management, master benefits plan, workers' compensation program, and HR technology along with expert support.
With an ASO, your business remains the sole employer of record. You get payroll administration services, plus any other HR services you choose, such as benefits administration, HR support, or time and attendance.
An HCM solution is an HR technology platform backed by people who help you get the most out of it. You manage HR with G&A's tools and training, and our team is available when you need expert guidance.
*Important Legal Disclaimer: Nothing in this material is intended to be, nor should it be construed as, legal or financial advice. Read more.